10 Best Used Sports Cars With Lower Maintenance Costs
Not all sports cars are good investments when it comes to reliability and maintenance, but there are a few that are worth the money.
It's hard to deny the appeal of sports cars. But let’s face it; high-performance vehicles don't always carry the strongest reputations for reliability. Due to higher stresses on engines and chassis, maintenance costs can easily exceed the expected figure.
Today, many sports cars on the market share parts, which can cut down on production costs and help improve dependability. As a few examples, the Ford Mustang GT uses an engine that shares its guts with the 5.0-liter V8 found in the F-150, the Mazda MX-5’s 2.0-liter engine is from a family crossover, and the Toyota GR86 shares most of its parts with the Subaru BRZ.
This kind of clever parts sharing has resulted in some properly reliable sports cars with yearly maintenance costs that aren’t much worse than typical family cars and SUVs. Here are ten of our favorite second-hand sports cars with low maintenance costs.
All informational data for the vehicles on this List was retrieved from the manufacturer's own websites, as well as popular automotive websites such as Kelly Blue Book, Edmunds, CarEdge, J.D. Power, TuningPro, Car Survey, Consumer Reports, and RepairPal.
Manufacturer
Ford Motor Company
Production Years
2010-Present
Configuration
V8
Displacement
5.0-Liter
Power
460 hp
Torque
420 lb-ft
Fuel
Gasoline
Noteworthy Applications
Ford Mustang GT, Ford F-150
As the nameplate that practically created the accessible muscle car, the Mustang GT has always been a sports car for the everyman. Part of that accessibility comes from its relative reliability as a performance vehicle. The newest Mustang GTs only reinforce that reputation with their powerful, yet durable 5.0-liter Coyote V8 engines.
The sixth generation Mustang was the first to be updated to a sports car thanks to its beefier engine, much-improved suspension, and looks. Even with a 5.0-liter naturally aspirated V8, the Mustang will only set owners back around $360 per year in maintenance and around $1,915 over the course of five years. Not bad for a comfortable cruiser.
RELATED: 12 Cheap Sports Cars That Can Outrun A Mustang GT
Manufacturer
Mazda
Production Years
2012-Present
Configuration
Inline-4
Displacement
2.0-Liter
Power
155-181 hp
Torque
148-155 lb-ft
Fuel
Gasoline
Noteworthy Applications
Mazda MX-5, Mazda3, Mazda CX-30
The Mazda MX-5 is now in its fourth generation, with a fifth generation on the horizon. The MX-5 encapsulates the traditional sports car philosophy of small dimensions, punchy engine, and rear-wheel-drive – just like the British sports cars of the 1950s and 1960s.
The ND MX-5 uses a 2.0-liter naturally aspirated engine mated to either a 6-speed manual or an automatic. But most people go for the manual. The MX-5 costs around $1,500 to maintain over the course of five years – or approximately $300 per year.
Manufacturer
Toyota/Subaru
Production Years
2019-Present
Configuration
Flat-4
Displacement
2.4-Liter
Power
228-234 hp
Torque
184 lb-ft
Fuel
Gasoline
Noteworthy Applications
Toyota GR86, Subaru BRZ
The current Toyota GR86 is being heralded as one of the best bang-for-the-buck sports cars on sale. It boasts several improvements over the previous generation’s Toyota 86. Better suspension and chassis tuning and a more powerful engine come standard for the new model.
The GR86 is a collaboration between Toyota and Subaru, with the latter providing the grumbly Boxer four-cylinder engine. It's a solid, reliable option for daily driving, with an average yearly maintenance cost of around $244. However, it's worth noting that owners have reported engine troubles when pushing the GR86 during track use.
Manufacturer
General Motors
Production Years
2014-Present
Configuration
V8
Displacement
6.2-Liter
Power
455 hp
Torque
455 lb-ft
Fuel
Gasoline
Noteworthy Applications
Chevrolet Camaro, Chevrolet Corvette C7
The Chevrolet Camaro SS – like the Ford Mustang GT – switched from being a full-on muscle car to more of a sports car. The SS 1LE and ZL1 1LE are even track monsters, beating out the Shelby Mustang GT500 in the twisty stuff. Even the regular Camaro SS is an excellent lap-time hunter. The Camaro is expected to bow out after the 2023 model year.
Since the Camaro’s platform is shared with so many other GM vehicles – think Cadillac CT5 – the maintenance is pretty decent, coming in at $5 less than the Mustang GT over a five-year period. Expect to pay around $358 per year on general maintenance and repairs.
RELATED: 10 Sports Cars Nobody Wanted 25 Years Ago... Today They're Worth A Fortune
Manufacturer
BMW
Production Years
2015-Present
Configuration
Straight-6 Turbocharged
Displacement
3.0-Liter
Power
322-382 hp
Torque
332-368 lb-ft
Fuel
Gasoline
Noteworthy Applications
Toyota Supra, BMW M340i, BMW M240i
The fifth-gen Toyota Supra may not be everyone’s cup of petrol – since it is a BMW underneath and some enthusiasts have an issue with that – but it is one really good car. The Supra features the best straight-6 currently available and punches way above its weight class.
With the BMW-ness, one would expect a higher maintenance cost, but it is actually less than the Ford and Chevy’s. Expect to pay around $283 per year and a big total of $1,483 over a five-year period. Not at all bad for a turbocharged engine which is getting compared more and more to the legendary 2JZ from the Mk4 Supra.
Manufacturer
Nissan
Production Years
2008-2020
Configuration
V6
Displacement
3.7-Liter
Power
325-350 hp
Torque
275 lb-ft
Fuel
Gasoline
Noteworthy Applications
Nissan 370Z, Infiniti G37, Mitsubishi Proudia 370GT
The Nissan 370Z is a legend in its own right, building upon the popularity of the 350Z before it. The 3.7-liter naturally aspirated V6 screamed its way to redline and is a great motor to tune – with some owners adding twin turbos for some extra oomph.
The 370Z was in production for an impressive 13 years before being replaced with the current Nissan Z – which really should’ve been called the 400Z for clarification purposes. Thanks to the relative simplicity of the drivetrain, the 370Z costs around $1,716 over five years and $323 per year. It is a brilliant example of Japanese reliability.
RELATED: 10 Cheap Performance Cars That'll Outrun A Dodge Challenger
Manufacturer
Honda
Production Years
1999-2009
Configuration
Inline-4
Displacement
2.0-2.2-Liter
Power
237-247 hp
Torque
153-152 lb-ft
Fuel
Gasoline
Noteworthy Applications
Honda S2000
The S2000 was Honda’s answer to the likes of the Mazda MX-5 but with a lot more power. The S2000 featured a 2.0-liter inline-4, but it revved to an incredible 9,000 rpm. The engine also had Honda’s famous V-TEC camshaft system, so it made great power throughout the rev range.
The S2000 is an awesome sports car – properly designed and engineered. As a result, it is extremely reliable and on average costs just $310 per year to maintain – given that nothing major broke. The S2000 has a host of aftermarket modifications that just improve the car overall.
Manufacturer
Mercedes-Benz/AMG
Production Years
2002-2011
Configuration
V8 Supercharged
Displacement
5.4-Liter
Power
470-510 hp
Torque
500-530 lb-ft
Fuel
Gasoline
Noteworthy Applications
Mercedes-Benz SL, Mercedes-Benz G-Class, Mercedes-Benz S-Class
The R230 Mercedes-Benz SL55 AMG is often called a ‘supercar killer’ as its 5.4-liter supercharged V8 can produce a lot more power than stock with some basic modifications. The 510 hp is already a lot, but some people have gotten over 700 hp from the engine without much difficulty.
The SL55 was designed and built during the last years when Mercedes over-engineered their cars, meaning that everything is dependable and sturdy. The only possible problem is with the ABC suspension system. While the fuel costs may be a bit high, the actual maintenance costs range between $105 and $539 on a yearly basis – given nothing needs replacing. Not at all bad for a now 20-year-old car.
RELATED: 10 Used Sports Cars Buyers Almost Always Regret Buying
Manufacturer
Honda
Production Years
1991-2005
Configuration
V6
Displacement
3.0-3.2-Liter
Power
252-290 hp
Torque
210 lb-ft
Fuel
Gasoline
Noteworthy Applications
Honda NSX, Acura NSX, Honda Inspire
The Honda NSX – called the Acura NSX in North America – was the Japanese company’s answer to the likes of Ferrari; the biggest differences were that the NSX was faster, more reliable, and much cheaper to purchase, forcing Ferrari to rethink their entire strategy – much like the current Formula One season.
The NSX is one of the few Japanese cars that are at the top of the JDM fan list, sporting a V6 and a mid-engine layout. Because it is Honda, everything is meticulously designed and engineered, so maintenance is relatively easy and affordable, ranging between $250 and $500 per year. Maintenance may be on the cheaper side – but beware of the expensive repairs and parts.
Manufacturer
BMW
Production Years
2019-Present
Configuration
Straight-6 Twin-Turbocharged
Displacement
3.0-Liter
Power
450-510 hp
Torque
400-480 lb-ft
Fuel
Gasoline
Noteworthy Applications
BMW M3, BMW M4, BMW X3M
Finally, we get to the current standard for the sports car, the BMW M4. While many would argue the Porsche 911 is the standard, others believe that the 911 has shifted more into the supercar class – or at the very least, the super sports car class.
The BMW M4 has the best straight-6 engine on sale, the S58, which produces more performance than BMW lets on. The M4 is also in the league of Ferraris and Lamborghinis in terms of 0-60 mph times but costs much less. On top of this, the M4 – and its M3 sibling – is reliable and costs around $376 on average for maintenance. Not bad for a car that can embarrass pretty much anything in its class.
By subscribing, you agree to our Privacy Policy and may receive occasional deal communications; you can unsubscribe anytime.
Michael De Kock is passionate about cars and everything from avocados to particle accelerators. He has studied psychology and knows a little bit about fixing cars (old Land Rovers mostly). He also blogs and has a book, 125 Creative Writing Prompts for Petrolheads, available on Amazon. His philosophy in life: Stop the hate - Adopt a V8.
Scott is a passionate automotive enthusiast from the Kansas City area. He enjoys weird cars, road trips, motorsport, and car stories. Scott is a member of the Midwest Automotive Media Association (MAMA).
sports carsreliable sports carsAvg. Yearly MoverEst. Maintenance Costs Over First 5 Years: Recalls: Problems Owners Report: Avg. Yearly MaioverEst. Maintenance Costs Over First 5 Years: Recalls:Problems Owners Report: Avg. Yearly Maintenance Costs: Est. Maintenance Costs Over First 5 Years: Recalls: Problems Owners Report: Avg. Yearly Maintenance Costs: Est. Maintenance Costs Over First 5 Years: Recalls: Problems Owners Report: Avg. Yearly Maintenance Costs: Est. Maintenance Costs Over First 5 Years: Recalls: Problems Owners Report: Avg. Yearly Maintenance Costs: Est. Maintenance Costs Over First 5 Years: Recalls:Problems Owners Report: Avg. Yearly Maintenance Costs: Est. Maintenance Costs Over First 5 Years: Recalls: Problems Owners Report: Avg. Yearly Maintenance Costs: Est. Maintenance Costs Over First 5 Years: Recalls: Problems Owners Report: Avg. Yearly Maintenance Costs: Est. Maintenance Costs Over First 5 Years: Recalls: Problems Owners Report: Avg. Yearly Maintenance Costs: Est. Maintenance Costs Over First 5 Years: Recalls: Problems Owners Report: